Transfer pricing benchmark check · Malaysia
From database export to an IRBM-ready benchmark.
AI screens the comparables, code calculates the 37.5th–62.5th percentile range the Rules require, and your tax team makes the call. Every reason for every decision stays on file for when IRBM asks.
- ITA 1967 s.140A
- TP Rules 2023
- MTPG 2024
- 37.5th–62.5th percentile
- TNMM
Product
Column AColumn DColumn FColumn HColumn K–MColumn N–PEvery screening step is run by code, not a language model; the results are reproducible.
47 → 4747 → 3131 → 2525 → 2121 → 1717 → 1414 → 12| Entity | MSIC | NCP FY2024 | Status | Recorded reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alfa Manufacturing Sdn Bhd | 10799 | 5.6% | Accepted | Comparable functional profile |
| Beta Industri Sdn Bhd | 10799 | 4.7% | Accepted | Comparable functional profile |
| Gamma Foods Pte Ltd (SG) | 10799 | 6.2% | Rejected | Foreign. insufficient verifiable data |
| Delta Makanan Sdn Bhd | 10799 | 6.1% | Accepted | Comparable functional profile |
| Epsilon Sarana Sdn Bhd | 10799 | -2.3% | Rejected | Persistent losses |
| Zeta Niaga Sdn Bhd | 46323 | 5.4% | Needs review | Possible associated person: decision needed |
| Eta Olahan Sdn Bhd | 10799 | 5.0% | Accepted | Comparable functional profile |
| Theta Prima Sdn Bhd | 10799 | 8.9% | Rejected | Turnover below 10% of tested party |
Benchmark workpaper (XLSX)
- Tested party summary
- Methodology & legal basis
- Arm's length range (37.5th–62.5th percentile)
- Arm's length conclusion
Working Paper (XLSX)
- 47 candidates + status
- Accept/reject reason per row
- Current-year ratio per comparable
- Reviewer override trail
Interface illustration of the Malaysian ruleset, currently in development. Entity names and figures are examples, not client data.
01The problem
Benchmarking is heavy work, and its risk stays with you for years
Hundreds of candidates, reviewed by hand
One database export can hold hundreds of entities. Assessing them one by one eats working days no budget ever allowed for.
Rejection reasons never written down
IRBM can request your contemporaneous documentation years later and expects it within 14 days. By then, the reason a comparable was struck out often lives only in the head of someone who has since left.
Documentation by copy and paste
Last year's narrative is pasted in again and the numbers updated by hand. Miss one cell and the whole conclusion is wrong.
02How it works
Six steps, from raw file to finished document
- 01
Upload the export
Upload the comparables database export you already have. Columns are recognised automatically.
- 02
Quantitative screening
Industry code (MSIC), active status, current-year data, independence and the 10% turnover test are applied by code.
- 03
Qualitative screening
Functional profile, possible associated persons and loss patterns are flagged for review.
- 04
Your decision
Accept, reject or override the system's result. Every decision is stored with its reason.
- 05
Range calculation
PLI ratios and the 37.5th–62.5th percentile range are calculated deterministically, with the median at the range's mid-point, as the Rules prescribe.
- 06
Export the documentation
Benchmarking workpaper (XLSX) and TP bundle in the studio (.md + summary), with audit trail. Final PDF report is not available yet.
03Why Fiskora
Transfer pricing work you can stand behind
Numbers calculated by code
Every ratio, percentile and mid-point median is computed deterministically, not estimated by AI.
Research and documentation drafts
A language model can draft comparable-research notes and documentation chapters from the run. Your team reviews before use. This is not tax advice.
The decision stays with you
The system screens and suggests. Your tax team decides and takes responsibility.
A complete audit trail
Every acceptance, rejection and its reason is recorded automatically. Ready to trace when IRBM audits.
04Code vs AI
Clear from the start: what code calculates, what AI drafts
| Task | Calculated by code | Drafted by AI | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Industry code, active status & data availability screening | Calculated by code | MTPG 2024 para 4.21 | |
| Associated-person (independence) test | Calculated by code | ITA 1967 s.139, 140A(5) | |
| Turnover size test (≥ 10% of tested party) | Calculated by code | MTPG 2024 para 4.21(b) | |
| Current-year data, no multiple-year averages | Calculated by code | TP Rules 2023 r.7(6)(b) | |
| PLI ratio & 37.5th–62.5th percentile range | Calculated by code | TP Rules 2023 r.13(5) | |
| Comparable functional profile summary | Drafted by AI | MTPG 2024 para 4.21(a) | |
| Comparability analysis narrative | Drafted by AI | MTPG 2024 Ch. 4 | |
| Final conclusion & sign-off | Your tax team | ITA 1967 s.140A | |
05Integration
Fits into the workflow you already run
No API
Fiskora takes the database export you already have. There is no technical integration to build.
Enters at the screening stage
After database extraction, before document drafting, exactly where the manual work is heaviest.
Save & resume
Work is saved per project. Stop today, pick it up next week with the full context intact.
Reviewer control
Every system decision can be overridden, and the override survives when the analysis is re-run.
06Built for Malaysian rules
The Malaysian range, not the OECD default
Most benchmarking tools default to the interquartile range. Malaysia doesn't: the Rules set the arm's length range at the 37.5th to 62.5th percentile, with the median at its mid-point, and IRBM may adjust to the median or above where comparability defects can't be quantified. In Fiskora you pick the Malaysian ruleset per benchmark: the range, the median and the workpaper's legal annex then follow the Rules and MTPG 2024 Example 2.2.
- ITA 1967 s.140A
- TP Rules 2023
- MTPG 2024
- 37.5th–62.5th percentile
- TNMM
07Product roadmap
Live in Indonesia. Malaysia is next.
Transfer pricing benchmark check. Indonesia
Transfer pricing benchmark check. Malaysia (Transfer Pricing Rules 2023)
Contemporaneous TP Documentation. Malaysia
08Pricing
Indonesia list prices
List prices on this page are Indonesia reference prices in rupiah. Malaysia pricing is set at onboarding. There is no card charge. A plan or add-on applies after Fiskora staff assign it to that organisation.
Client portfolio is on the plan. This list is for a firm workspace.
Trial
Freemonthly quotaTo test the studio on a real run.
- 5 seats
- 3 benchmarking runs
- 50.000 Fiskora Tokens
- Core modules; commodity and dispute off
Standard
Rp 4.900.000per monthFor a regular practice.
- 5 seats
- 30 benchmarking runs
- 500.000 Fiskora Tokens
- Equalisation; portfolio for firms
Pro
Rp 12.900.000per monthFor higher volume.
- 15 seats
- 100 benchmarking runs
- 2.000.000 Fiskora Tokens
- Higher client quota
Add-ons, that organisation only
- Commodity price test
Rp 1.900.000 / monthTurns the module on at standard. - Tax disputes
Rp 1.900.000 / monthTurns the module on at standard. - Country-by-country report (CbCR)
Rp 2.500.000 / monthWorking paper, CBC-1/2/3 and XML files ready to upload to Coretax. The CbCR notification stays on every plan. - Market reference
Rp 950.000 / monthMonthly commodity prices and interest rates, agreement search, trade unit values and patents. - 2 extra seats
Rp 700.000 / monthRaises the seat quota. Shared plans are not rewritten. - 5 extra runs
Rp 750.000 / monthAdds benchmarking runs for the current month. - 50.000 Fiskora Tokens
Rp 450.000 / monthAdds Fiskora Tokens for the current month.
An Orbis subscription is not included. Prices outside Indonesia are set at onboarding.
09Questions
Common questions
Fiskora is live for Indonesian tax teams. For Malaysia, the range calculation already follows the TP Rules 2023: 37.5th–62.5th percentile, median at the mid-point, single-year data. Malaysian screening defaults and an English workpaper are still in development, and we are looking for a small number of Malaysian tax teams to shape them with us.
Not for Malaysia. The TP Rules 2023 set the arm's length range at the 37.5th to 62.5th percentile of the data set, with the median at the mid-point of that range. Fiskora's Malaysian ruleset calculates exactly that, and flags that IRBM may adjust to the median or above where comparability defects can't be quantified (MTPG 2024 para 2.12).
Not on its own. Documentation is contemporaneous only if it is prepared before the tax return due date and contains everything subrule 4(2) of the Rules requires. Fiskora produces a verified, cited draft of the benchmarking; your team reviews and finalises it. Fiskora is not a substitute for a certified professional review.
No. Fiskora screens and drafts. The final decision, sign-off and responsibility stay with your tax team. Every system decision can be overridden, and the override is recorded.
No. Fiskora works from database exports you or your adviser already have. IRBM will not accept comparables without sufficient, verifiable information, so Fiskora checks for it as part of screening.
The Income Tax (Transfer Pricing) Rules 2023 and the Malaysia Transfer Pricing Guidelines 2024, including their criteria on current-year data, the 10% turnover test and associated persons. Every screening step can be traced to its source.
Work content is for your organisation and for platform staff who need it to operate the service. It is not used to train models. Audit events are not deleted. Details are in the privacy policy.
Start with one trial run
Register, finish onboarding, then upload an export. Trial quotas apply until staff assign another plan.